Snorkels: Yes or No? The Great Debate Among Dive Instructors

When it comes to diving, one question tends to ignite spirited debates among instructors around the globe: to wear a snorkel or not to wear a snorkel—that is indeed the question! The answer, however, is far from simple. With various diving agencies promoting different practices and philosophies, this topic has transformed into a significant point of contention within the diving community, leading to a rich exchange of perspectives.

The Case for Snorkels

Most diving agencies maintain that a snorkel should be carried during a dive, even if it’s not required to be worn at all times. The great news is that today’s snorkels are designed with convenience in mind, featuring models that roll up or bend to easily fit into a drysuit or BCD pocket. Personally, I find this approach much more practical, which often leads to playful comments on my videos from the "fun police" about my choice to go without a snorkel attached to my mask. For me, it makes sense to have it accessible without wearing it constantly. The moments when a snorkel is most useful are typically at the beginning or end of a dive, making it easy to grab when needed. Since I manage my air consumption effectively, I rarely find myself needing it and often swim at the surface using my regulator, especially if the seas are a bit choppy.

Regardless of where you stand on the issue of wearing a snorkel, there are several compelling reasons to consider it an essential tool for divers, particularly in specific situations:

1. Surface Breathing: Snorkels allow divers to breathe easily while floating on the surface, conserving tank air for underwater exploration. This feature is especially valuable during long surface swims or when waiting for a dive group to assemble.

2. Energy Efficiency: By utilizing a snorkel, divers can save their tank air for the underwater portion of their dive, ensuring a longer and more enjoyable experience beneath the waves.

3. Safety: In emergency situations, having a snorkel can provide an alternative means of breathing. If a diver experiences equipment failure or becomes disoriented, a snorkel can serve as a vital lifeline.

4. Wildlife Watching: Snorkeling can greatly enhance the experience of observing marine life at the surface. It allows divers to soak in the beauty of their surroundings before making the descent, enriching the overall adventure.

   
   

The Argument Against Snorkels

While the debate often centers around whether to wear a snorkel or not, another perspective focuses on the practicality of keeping the snorkel attached to the mask at all times. Let’s face it: having a snorkel affixed to your mask can sometimes look less than appealing. I can already hear the groans of snorkel enthusiasts as they read this!

Some diving agencies recommend against using snorkels for several reasons:

1. Potential for Injury: Snorkels can pose risks, such as entanglement with underwater flora or becoming a hindrance during rapid descents. In scenarios requiring quick reactions, a snorkel could complicate matters.

2. Discomfort: Many divers find snorkels cumbersome and uncomfortable, especially when they are not in use. The presence of a snorkel can lead to improper positioning and affect buoyancy control, both of which are crucial for a smooth diving experience.

3. Diving Conditions: In challenging environments, like strong currents or rough seas, snorkels can create additional complications. Managing both a snorkel and other diving gear can be cumbersome and may distract from the primary goal of safe exploration.

   
   

Finding Common Ground

Ultimately, the decision to use a snorkel may depend on individual preferences, diving conditions, and specific training guidelines. While many instructors stress the importance of having a snorkel on hand, they also emphasize the need for divers to be adaptable and well-versed in various techniques. Whether this includes using a snorkel or opting for alternative methods, flexibility is key.

As the diving world continues to evolve, it is essential for instructors and divers alike to stay informed and open-minded about different practices. The key is to prioritise safety and comfort while ensuring that divers are equipped with the skills necessary to enjoy their underwater experiences.

Conclusion

In the end, the snorkel debate may never reach a definitive conclusion. It highlights the diversity of opinions within the diving community and serves as a reminder that there is often more than one way to approach a situation. Whether you choose to dive with a snorkel or without, the most important thing is to enjoy the beauty of the underwater world safely and responsibly. Embrace the adventure, stay informed, and dive with confidence!